The Paradox of Change

"Change occurs when one becomes what he is, not when he tries to become what he is not."
-Arnold Beisser

What if being pushed to change, every day, every hour, every minute is just unfair? What if we can’t change? What if we don’t want to change? Should we have to change a core part of us? Why do we change? Are we changing for ourselves or are we changing for society?

These are questions that I have struggled to answer.

This journey is mine. I’ve walked on unsteady ground. I’ve trudged through murky waters. Day in and day out, I’ve worked to survive the journey. And now I’m told to change the journey. Create a new path. A journey that is easier to trudge. A journey that looks more pleasant to the naked eye. A path paved over MY path that I’ve created.

I fear that myself, my core identity, who I am as a person isn’t enough. I am X, but I need to be Y.  But why is Y valued over X?

I am me and I’m not sure I want to change that. I occasionally block. I occasionally struggle. And maybe that’s okay.

Maybe that’s enough. Maybe I am enough the way I am.

Don’t get me wrong. I believe in change. Life is all about change, growth, and striving to become a better version of yourself. But maybe change happens when we let go of our insecurities, remove our shield, and let society see us for all we have to offer, beyond our speech. If we don’t love ourselves and embrace our imperfections how can we expect society to welcome them? If we want change, we can be change just by being ourselves.

Beisser continued, "Change does not take place through a coercive attempt by the individual or by another person to change him, but it does take place if one takes the time and effort to be what he is - to be fully invested in his current positions."

I vow: to accept myself and all my vulnerabilities. To embrace the uncertainty, the struggle, the fear. To learn to love the chaotic harmony that stuttering creates. To strive towards better communication and work toward being a better version of myself but know that, under any conditions, do I have to. 

I will change for myself, but I will not change for societal expectations. And maybe the real change is about standing your ground - for who you are, for what you represent, for what you believe in.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The world doesn't understand stuttering

For 10 seconds everything stops. The room goes silent. My body is filled with struggle and desperation as I try to get the sound out. Fifty pairs of eyes glued on me, staring intently and curiously, as if I’m a mutant creature they’ve never seen before. I haven’t had someone blatantly laugh at me in years. But it didn’t take long to remember the feeling. Suddenly, I’m 15 again, in that high school classroom with everyone staring at me wondering why I can’t say my own name. They look at each other as I contort my face trying to say the sound. The silence is broken by shrieks of laughter, coming from the guy behind me. Joining him is the professor, who chuckles and says, “ooook we’re just going to move on then.” Instinctively, I turned to the guy laughing and asked, “What are you laughing at?” and added, “Just so you know, I stutter, that’s what that was. It takes me a little longer to talk.” Under his breath, he muttered “Sorry” and said no more. Not that day and not ever again. There a...
Read more

Treating 5% of the Disorder

Image
One of the founders of our field, Charles Van Riper, once said, "Stuttering is everything you do trying not to stutter." What does this actually mean and what are the implications? There is a growing divide between SLP's who specialize in stuttering on whether we should change the way a person who stutters talks (fluency shaping) or accept the stuttering, but modify the way the person stutters (stuttering modification). Fluency shaping, specifically the prolonged speech approach, is frequently adopted by many school-based SLP’s. It has a large evidence base and is relatively straightforward for SLP's to implement without having an extensive knowledge base of stuttering. It makes sense - connect each syllable, word, and phrase together, so that it becomes physically impossible to stutter. Fluency - check. But take this technique into real life and it often fails. Why? Because the answer is not what we think the answer is. It’s actually quite counterintuitive. ...
Read more

The Gift of Stuttering

It’s cliché among the stuttering self-help community to say that stuttering is a gift. Despite turning stuttering into a huge positive in my life, I never really considered it a gift. If it was a gift at all, it was an unwanted gift that I was forced to open and accept. A couple months ago, I attended a one day workshop sponsored by the New York City NSA chapters. Chris Constantino and Emma Alpern posed this question: Is our pride reflective of unsatisfactory therapy or is there something special about stuttering? Here’s what they said: Stuttering gives us access to experiences that are not available to fluent speakers. The vulnerability of stuttering allows for greater intimacy than fluent speech. It allows us to relate to people in unique ways . We have an increased likelihood of raw moments. These are the moments that separate the monotony of daily life. These moments add meaning and texture to our lives. We find excitement in the unpredictable. We have a richness of e...
Read more